Among the many traditions this time of year is eggnog, that thick, golden, creamy spiced drink that has become a hallmark of the holiday season.
The word “nog,” according to the Oxford English Dictionary, first was used in 1693, but referred to a bottle of strong beer. The custard-like drink served cold, with seasonal spices (and often the addition of bourbon or rum) most likely was derived from posset, a drink made of hot curdled milk with spiced warm ale or wine that often was used in medieval Britain as a remedy. Sometimes, it was served in a small wooden cup called a noggin. The drink made its way to the American colonies in the 18th century, where eggs and rum were plentiful, and eggnog evolved into what we savor today.
In metro area restaurants, you can enjoy various versions of the spiced, spiked drink near a fireplace, on patios or at holiday-themed pop-ups — and always with lots of cheer.
Credit: Handout
Credit: Handout
Sip a version of eggnog called Santa’s Milk and Cookies, from the holiday pop-up menu, under the bauble-bedecked ceiling of the Select (6405 Blue Stone Road, Sandy Springs. 770-637-2240, theselectatl.com). A serving also comes with two warm chocolate cookies.
It might not be the best match for a fresh selection of oysters, but the eggnog at Watchman’s (99 Krog St., Atlanta. 404-254-0141, watchmansatl.com) is dreamy after a stroll on the Beltline. Miles Macquarrie mixes navy rum (a blend of aged rums), pineapple rum, coconut, maple and nutmeg for a tropical holiday vacation in a glass.
Credit: Whitney Flockart Photography
Credit: Whitney Flockart Photography
All the fun vibes of the film “National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation” are on the menu at the Third Door (131 Church St., Marietta. 470-361-0370, thethirddoor.net). Its pop-up homage, dubbed A Church Street Vacation, has a version of nog that melds cream, a sherry blend, egg and walnut bitters.
Credit: Terry Koval
Credit: Terry Koval
Chef-owner Terry Koval made an illuminated sign pointing the way to the eggnog at Deer and the Dove (155 Sycamore St., Decatur. 404-748-4617, deerdove.com). A blend of bourbon, rum, brandy, egg, cream, sugar and spices, it is served in Koval’s great aunt’s antique glasses.
Credit: Handout
Credit: Handout
Meaning “little coconut,” a coquito sometimes is called island eggnog, or Puerto Rican eggnog. For chef-owner Hector Santiago of El Super Pan (675 Ponce de Leon Ave. NE, Atlanta. 404-600-2465; 455 Legends Place, Atlanta. 404-521-6500, elsuperpan.com), coquito is a Christmas tradition served at home and at his restaurants. He crafts the dense, silky drink with house-made Puerto Rican spiced rum, coconut cream, coconut milk, eggs and spices (clove, nutmeg and cinnamon).
You can sip a coquito made with 12-year-old Flor de Cana rum out of a glass milk jug on the patio of Buena Vida Tapas + Sol, (385 N. Angier Ave. NE, Atlanta. 404-948-2312, buenavidatapas.com), nestled between the Beltline and the historic Old Fourth Ward neighborhood. It pairs well with one of the restaurant’s design-your-own charcuterie boards or freshly made churros.
Credit: Jarrett Stieber
Credit: Jarrett Stieber
Little Bear (71 Georgia Ave., Atlanta. 404-500-5396, littlebearatl.com) has a vegan Pacanquito that is booze-forward, with spiced brandy and overproof rum. It goes well with food. Owner Jarrett Stieber said the Summerhill bar substitutes local benne seeds and pecans, which bar manager Charles Howk turns into milk, for the coconut normally in a coquito.
Credit: Handout
Credit: Handout
Newly opened LaRayia’s Bodega (675 Ponce de Leon Ave. NE, Atlanta. 404-900-7900, larayiasbodega.com) makes sipping a coquito at home easy and delicious. The Black-owned, organic, vegan shop is all about Caribbean flavor, and you’ll find it in the pretty bottle of ready-to-go coquito.
Credit: Brinson Renda
Credit: Brinson Renda
You also can try a coquito at home with a kit that comes complete with Guatemalan aged rum cut to proof with fresh coconut water. Coconut Cartel partnered with Coquito NYC to create the holiday drink kit ($94.99 at shopcoconutcartel.com), which includes simple instructions and a bottle of Anejo rum, cans of sweetened condensed milk, evaporated milk, organic coconut milk, vanilla extract, a signature blend of Coquito NYC spices, straws and four custom coquito glass bottles.
Another Latin American drink, Mexico’s rompope, first was made by nuns in a 17th century Puebla convent. It includes almond paste whisked into a base of milk, cinnamon and eggs, with or without rum. A bottled version of the drink is available at larger metro area liquor stores.
Sign up for the AJC Food and Dining Newsletter
Read more stories like this by liking Atlanta Restaurant Scene on Facebook, following @ATLDiningNews on Twitter and @ajcdining on Instagram.
About the Author
