She once seemed like a doting mother. Neighbors remember her hosting cookouts after church, bouncing a baby on her hip as she chatted with friends.
Then Isabel Martinez snapped. She’d struggled with mental illness in the past but after her father’s death two years ago, something inside her came apart. One morning in July 2017, Martinez fatally stabbed her husband and four of her children, then dialed 911.
This week, she pleaded guilty but mentally ill.
“There was no way she wasn’t going to be found guilty of these murders,” Gwinnett District Attorney Danny Porter said Wednesday. “I believe guilty but mentally ill was the best outcome we could get.”
Martinez, 35, isn’t eligible for parole for at least 30 years, possibly longer given the many crimes she pleaded guilty to. In the unlikely event she ever leaves confinement, she will be deported back to her native Mexico, Porter said.
Following her pleas, entered Tuesday evening, Martinez will be referred to a state facility where she’ll receive mental health treatment and evaluation.
“She may never get out of that,” Porter said.
Had the case gone to trial, jurors would have heard horrific details. Investigators responding to the scene found the bodies of Martin Romero, 33, and four children: 2-year-old Axel, 4-year-old Dillan, 7-year-old Dacota and 10-year-old Isabela Martinez.
Martinez’ daughter Diana, then 9, was seriously injured but survived. She told investigators her mother told her she was “going to the sky to see Jesus.” Diana now lives with other relatives.
Gwinnett County Sheriff's Office
Gwinnett County Sheriff's Office
Several family members were in the courtroom to witness Martinez’ guilty pleas. None spoke. The morning after her arrest, her mental health already appeared to be an issue. She smiled at television cameras and flashed a double “thumbs up” during initial court proceedings.
Martinez has schizophrenia, and her mental health kept prosecutors from seeking the death penalty, Porter said.
Steven Gaskell, a forensic psychologist with offices in Illinois and Atlanta, said Martinez wasn’t a cold-blooded killer but propelled by mental illness.
RELATED | Mother pleads guilty, but mentally ill to killing 5
READ | Murder in Gwinnett: Mom charged with killing 4 children, father
MORE | Gwinnett mom felt 'devil-like spirit' before stabbing children, husband
“What does she have to gain from killing them all? Probably nothing,” said Gaskell, who was not involved with the case. “A logical reason would be she was having delusions.”
Still, Martinez appeared to know what she was doing, Gaskell said. She called police and concocted a story, initially blaming someone else for her actions. That indicates she understood she had done something wrong, he said.
“It’s really hard to meet the criteria for ‘not guilty by reason of insanity,’” Gaskell said.
Prosecutor Richard Vandever called it one of the toughest cases he’s ever worked.
“There are no winners in this case,” he said. “There are none.”
GUILTY BUT MENTALLY ILL
- Under Georgia law, "mentally ill" means having a disorder of thought or mood which significantly impairs judgment, behavior, capacity to recognize reality, or ability to cope with the ordinary demands of life. However, the term "mental illness" shall not include a mental state manifested only by repeated unlawful or antisocial conduct.
- A plea of guilty but mentally ill at the time of the crime or a plea of guilty but with intellectual disability shall not be accepted until the defendant has undergone examination by a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist and the court has examined the psychological or psychiatric reports, held a hearing on the issue of the defendant's mental condition, and is satisfied that there is a factual basis that the defendant was mentally ill at the time of the offense.
