A tuna melt sandwich that’s an inch thick, with filling light as air ... African nut soup that wards off the chill of autumn ... crisp, golden tater tots that aren’t weighed down with oil — these are just a few of the unfussy bites that await when you step inside Motorboat.

Open since early September, the sandwich shop and bar is the latest venture from Tim Catalfo, who also owns Bantum Pub and Big Game, both located in the Old Fourth Ward.

The decor of Motorboat has a retro water sports theme. (Courtesy of Praim Siribothi)

Credit: Praim Siribothi

icon to expand image

Credit: Praim Siribothi

With Motorboat, Catalfo has tried to create the feel of a boathouse on a lake, beach or shoreline — a place you can unwind with an order of those finely fried tater tots and a drink.

The full bar offers a handful of house cocktails, including what essentially is a black Manhattan, as well as a smooth, standout version of an el diablo that comes with the burn of jalapeño and the reddish hue of crème de cassis.

Beer drinkers will find a list of 18 that includes canned and bottled brews, with four on tap. Wine drinkers are left to choose between four unimpressive grocery-store finds.

A burn the sails cocktail at Motorboat is a smooth version of an el diablo that comes with the burn of jalapeño and the reddish hue of crème de cassis. (Courtesy of Praim Siribothi)

Credit: Praim Siribothi

icon to expand image

Credit: Praim Siribothi

There are a dozen sandwiches on the menu, and the price range ($8-$15) is right. All the handhelds, with the exception of the Chicago Italian beef, are made with Alon’s bread. And numerous meats are prepared in-house. The sandwiches come with a pickle, a bag of chips or tots, a pasta salad, or a side salad for an upcharge.

Apart from a veggie version with roasted eggplant, red peppers and zucchini, whose bread quickly turned soggy, we gave a thumbs-up to the sandwiches: a tuna melt; a Rueben (and its shaved turkey counterpart, a Rachel, both with an impressive Russian dressing); Chicago Italian beef; and a honey-roasted pork sandwich. The latter, with savory, juicy pulled pork, might be improved with a change of bread, though. The pork is piled on soft pan de mie, and the slightly sweet bun combined with the honey-tinged pork and a slaw that leaned sweet was too much sugar for my taste.

All sandwiches at Motorboat come with chips. Substituting tater tots is worth the $2.50 upcharge. (Courtesy of Praim Siribothi)

Credit: Praim Siribothi

icon to expand image

Credit: Praim Siribothi

The muffuletta showcased the multi-meat flavors of the New Orleans classic, but traditionalists might scoff at this version. The layers were sandwiched between focaccia, instead of pillowy, round Sicilian sesame bread, and the whole thing was pressed instead of standing a mile high. Still, this monster of a sandwich was satisfying, even if it wanted for more olive salad.

A fried perch sandwich, clam roll and soft-shell crab sandwich are all are to be added soon. I’ll look forward to trying those, as well as the daily specials that bring variety to a meal at Motorboat, such as tater tots loaded with meaty sloppy Joe sauce; and New England clam chowder (although the diced carrots and corn kernels that bobbed in the bowl were a bit of a head-scratcher, as well as the side of shredded cheddar cheese as a garnish).

Motorboat's muffuletta breaks with tradition by using focaccia instead of round Sicilian sesame bread. The handheld also is pressed instead of standing a mile high. (Courtesy of Praim Siribothi)

Credit: Praim Siribothi

icon to expand image

Credit: Praim Siribothi

The two soups deserved their dedicated spot on the menu. Basil cream of tomato soup was as thick as a bisque and not acidic. African nut stew — a hearty soup chock-full of sweet potato, chicken and kale, and swirled with peanut butter — is exclusive to Motorboat. But the restaurant might do well to heat its soup bowls; soups this good deserve to stay warm longer.

Unlike most sandwich shops, Motorboat is a full-service restaurant. Service was speedy, with orders arriving quickly. On one visit, a server enthusiastically ticked off his picks; on another, a different staff member was mostly indifferent — except when it came to the strawberry cornbread shortcake. I’m more than happy to hand over $8 for this dessert, which brought moist cornbread with substance — whole kernels of corn, macadamia nuts, chocolate chips — topped with whipped cream, strawberries and blueberries.

Motorboat's hearty African nut stew is a cozy dish for fall. (Courtesy of Praim Siribothi)

Credit: Praim Siribothi

icon to expand image

Credit: Praim Siribothi

I was less pleased to discover a 3.5% credit card transaction surcharge that appeared in fine print on the bill — and was not advertised on the menu, website or mentioned verbally by servers.

Still, Motorboat has a model that works: easy, affordably priced sandwiches, salads, soups, sides and sips, served in a casual, inviting space.

Catalfo is so confident that he plans to open another location in Chattanooga. From there, he hopes to chart a course toward franchiseland. Anchors away!


MOTORBOAT

2 out of 4 stars (very good)

Food: casual sandwich shop and bar

Service: speedy but detached at times

Noise level: low

Recommended dishes: bow tie pasta salad, basil cream of tomato soup, African nut stew, lamb meatballs, tater tots, muffuletta, tuna sandwich, Rachel sandwich, cornbread strawberry shortcake

Vegetarian dishes: bow tie pasta salad, creamy deli coleslaw, basil cream of tomato soup, tater tots, white bean hummus, veggie sandwich, egg salad sandwich

Alcohol: full bar, limited house cocktails, numerous craft and macro beers

Price range: $20-$35 (without drinks, tax and gratuity); restaurant charges 3.5% credit card transaction fee

Hours: 11 a.m.-midnight Sundays-Wednesdays, 11 a.m.-2 a.m. Thursdays-Saturdays

Accessibility: zero-step entry, half-flight stairs to lower-level dining area

Parking: free in lot and on side streets

Nearest MARTA station: 1.5 miles from North Avenue

Reservations: accepted but not required

Outdoor dining: no

Takeout: available in-person only; no third-party pickup or delivery

Address, phone: 710 Ponce de Leon Ave. NE, Atlanta; 404-963-7156

Website: motorboatsandwichbar.com

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution’s dining critics conduct reviews anonymously. Reservations are not made in their name, nor do they provide restaurants with advance notice about their visits. Our critics always make multiple visits, sample the full range of the menu and pay for all of their meals. AJC dining critics wait at least one month after a new restaurant has opened before visiting.

Sign up for the AJC Food and Dining Newsletter

Read more stories like this by liking Atlanta Restaurant Scene on Facebook, following @ATLDiningNews on X and @ajcdining on Instagram.