Beer Town: Pontoon Brewing reopening in Sandy Springs after brief closure

After that, the Sandy Springs brewery mainly focused on barrel aging, wild ales and experimental beers, until Oct. 28, 2023, when Pontoon suddenly closed both brewery locations and filed for bankruptcy.

O’Keefe blamed the failure of a distributor to pay for product as the primary reason.

Credit: Bob Townsend

Credit: Bob Townsend

Only the Sandy Springs location at 8601 Dunwoody Place is reopening; Pontoon will be liquidating the equipment in Tucker as part of its bankruptcy agreement.

“The taproom in Sandy Springs had a lot more traffic,” O’Keefe said. “We’re going to bring back all of production here, with our 10-barrel, four-vessel system. We’ve got about a 5,000-barrel capacity, and a lot of it will be smaller batch beers and in-house releases that you can only get at the taproom.”

The bankruptcy process was tough, he said, but “it’s giving us new life in the sense that, when it’s completed, we will be debt-free.” He said the company now will focus on limited distribution and “quality over quantity.”

The Sandy Springs taproom is getting more bars with more taps, and the company hopes to find a permanent on-premises food partner.

“We’ll have more seating inside and outside,” O’Keefe said. “But we’ll have more limited hours, capitalizing on the times that have the most traffic.”

Credit: Bob Townsend

Credit: Bob Townsend

Many beer geeks know Pontoon best for its barrel-aged Brownie Batter stout and its annual Brownie Bash festival.

“I’m from the Tampa area, and a lot of the breweries down there are known for their big, big stouts,” O’Keefe said, adding that Brownie Batter “was a recipe that I developed when I was home brewing a long time ago. But at the brewery, we put it in barrels, and we haven’t looked back.”

Moving forward, O’Keefe is hoping for a return to the stability of Pontoon’s early days.

“We are in the middle of (raising equity) and we’re doing pretty well with it,” he said. “People are excited and there’s a lot of interest, because of the community that Pontoon has built over time. And we’re definitely going to have a more focused approach with our distribution.”

Pontoon appears to be a rare success story, given the number of Georgia breweries that closed last year and have not reopened. Certainly, Georgia’s restrictive beer laws have made it more difficult for small breweries to prosper.

It will be interesting to see whether O’Keefe and his crew can beat the odds.

Sign up for the AJC Food and Dining Newsletter

Read more stories like this by liking Atlanta Restaurant Scene on Facebook, following @ATLDiningNews on Twitter and @ajcdining on Instagram.