New reward offered in unsolved killing of elderly couple at Lake Oconee

This week marks the 10th anniversary of the grisly, unsolved killings of octogenarians Shirley and Russell Dermond
More reward money is being offered for information in the unsolved deaths of Shirley and Russell Dermond, a Lake Oconee couple in their 80s who were slain in 2014. On May 6, 2014, neighborhood friends in the Great Waters subdivision at Lake Oconee found Russell Dermond's decapitated body inside his two-car garage. Shirley Dermond's body turned up 10 days later in Lake Oconee.

Credit: Christian Boone

Credit: Christian Boone

More reward money is being offered for information in the unsolved deaths of Shirley and Russell Dermond, a Lake Oconee couple in their 80s who were slain in 2014. On May 6, 2014, neighborhood friends in the Great Waters subdivision at Lake Oconee found Russell Dermond's decapitated body inside his two-car garage. Shirley Dermond's body turned up 10 days later in Lake Oconee.

In the wake of last week’s revelation of new DNA evidence in the unsolved slayings of Shirley and Russell Dermond at Georgia’s Lake Oconee, the reward has increased for information that leads to an arrest in the decade-old case.

Putnam County Sheriff Howard Sills on Monday said that late last week the FBI informed him the agency would be adding $20,000 to the case’s reward fund. Combined with the FBI’s offering, that fund now totals about $25,000.

The sheriff hopes the reward, which could possibly double if other donors come through, will spur tipsters.

“Here’s $25,000,” Sills said, addressing potential informants. “And there’s a possibility there’s another $30,000. And if you want to collect this, now’s the time to give us a call. Because if our DNA research pans out, we won’t need your call.”

The DNA that Sills referred to involved traces of cellular evidence detected on a clothing item that Russell Dermond, 88, had on at the time of his death.

On the morning of May 6, 2014, his decapitated body was found on the floor of his two-car garage in the Great Waters subdivision. It’s believed the killing took place a couple of days prior. The body of his wife, Shirley Dermond, 87, turned up May 16, 2014. It had been weighed down with concrete blocks and dumped in the water 5 miles down the lake.

The macabre, puzzling nature of the case has generated widespread interest and attracted the attention of numerous true-crime TV shows and podcasts. It has also prompted a number of tipsters to phone in what they think are useful hints or possibilities. So far none has proved helpful.

“The problem with this case,” Sills recently told The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, “is there’s no theory so far that fits it.”

Reward offerings in the case have fluctuated over the years. With this week marking the 10th anniversary of the killings, officials expect news coverage of the crimes to generate a fresh round of potential tips.