In a case filled with dramatic twists and unforeseen turns, Monday's sentencing hearing for convicted killer Justin Ross Harris is expected to proceed without any big surprises.
Harris, 36, found guilty of intentionally leaving his 22-month-old son Cooper inside a hot car to die, faces a maximum sentence of life in prison without parole plus 42 years. And he's likely to get it, or something very close, based on the heinous nature of the June 2014 crime and the criteria Cobb County Superior Court Judge Mary Staley Clark will follow to arrive at a decision.
Credit: WSB-TV
Credit: WSB-TV
Input from jurors. Staley Clark said she would discuss sentencing with each of the 12 Glynn County jurors who decided Harris' fate. Though they declined interview requests, the six-man, six-woman panel told the prosecution team in a post-verdict meeting that, from the outset of their deliberations, there was near-unanimity that Harris was guilty.
Defense co-counsel Bryan Lumpkin confirmed as much in an exclusive interview with The Atlanta Journal-Constitution on the day after the verdict.
“There was not that sense of the gravity of having convicted someone of such a horrible crime,” Lumpkin said. One juror appeared conflicted, he said, but for “the rest of them (it) was just like a mix and mingle, basically. That was really bothersome.”
Mitigating circumstances. A troubled upbringing. Drug or alcohol addiction. Genuine remorse. These are common mitigating circumstances a judge might consider that could lead to a more lenient sentence. None are applicable here, however, and Harris' defense team has indicated they will introduce little to no evidence at the hearing.
Credit: John Carrington
Credit: John Carrington
What the state recommends. Cobb District Attorney Vic Reynolds' decision not to seek the death penalty for Harris was roundly criticized in the public arena, particularly in light of the agonizing death suffered by little Cooper. "Leave him in a HOT jail cell for life" tweeted one person following Reynolds' announcement in September 2014. Another took satisfaction in the thought that although the state will not seek the death penalty, "his prison mates will."
The state hasn’t said what sentence they’ll suggest, but lead prosecutor Chuck Boring’s comments the day after the verdict spoke volumes.
“What do you do when you’ve got somebody that’s been proven guilty of intentionally cooking a child in a car?” he said.
Harris' next home. The former Home Depot web developer is awaiting his sentence at the Cobb jail. It's not yet known where he'll serve his time — that decision will be made following an evaluation at Jackson State Prison after sentencing.
Credit: John Carrington
Credit: John Carrington
Only the beginning? Following Staley Clark's decision on Monday, the defense will have 30 days to appeal. Lead defense attorney Maddox Kilgore has made it clear that he plans to pursue every legal avenue at his disposal to exonerate Harris.
"There were breakdowns in this process that occurred," Kilgore said. "There were breakdowns in the investigation. There were breakdowns in the pre-trial phase, the motions phase. And there were breakdowns in the trial. It's our belief those breakdowns affected the verdict."
“We’re going to have our day before the Supreme Court of Georgia,” he said. “Hopefully at that juncture some of these breakdowns will come to light and we’ll have another chance at trial.”
----------------
COUNTS AND SENTENCING GUIDELINES
Ross Harris was found guilty on all eight counts.
Count 1. Malice murder. This is Georgia's equivalent of "first-degree murder" (although Georgia law has no such charge). It asserts intent. The indictment charges that Harris "did unlawfully and with malice aforethought cause the death of Cooper Harris."
Sentence: Life (minimum 30 years)
Count 2. Felony murder, count one. In felony murder, the defendant causes the death of another during the commission of a felony. In count one against Harris, the "underlying" felony was cruelty to children in the first degree.
Sentence: Life (minimum 30 years)
Count 3. Felony murder, count two. In count two, the underlying felony was cruelty to children in the second degree.
Sentence: Life (minimum 30 years)
Count 4. First-degree cruelty to children. Goes to intent; i.e., the defendant meant to inflict harm. The indictment says Harris "did maliciously cause Cooper … cruel and excessive physical pain."
Sentence: 5 to 20 years
Count 5. Second-degree cruelty to children. This charge is not concerned with intent but goes more to what the defendant failed to do and the consequences of that failure. The state alleges that Harris "did, with criminal negligence, cause Cooper Harris … cruel and excessive physical pain."
Sentence: 1 to 10 years
Count 6. Sexual exploitation of children. Relating to Harris' attempts to persuade a minor female to provide him images of "her genital and pubic area."
Sentence: 1 to 10 years
Count 7. Dissemination of harmful material to minors, count one (misdemeanor). The first relates to texts Harris sent to a minor female containing "explicit and detailed verbal descriptions and narrative accounts of sexual excitement and sexual conduct."
Sentence: up to 1 year
Count 8. Dissemination of harmful material to minors, count two (misdemeanor). The second involves Harris' sending images of his erect penis to minor females.
Sentence: up to 1 year
About the Author
